
Genes mean ladies like friends and partners that smell like their father.
Bachelors - ditch the Old Spice and don your prospective father-in-laws clothes. Women prefer the scent of their dad, a study shows, and may choose their friends and partners accordingly.
Nervous new boyfriends can live or die by the nod of a dates daunting dad. But Carole Ober and her team at the University of Chicago in Illinois have found a more fundamental fatherly influence: women prefer the smells of men whose gene selection matches their dads1.
Could this be a female Oedipus complex? "Its possible we would choose someone who smells like our dad," says team member Martha McClintock. If so, it could help women choose partners who share a selection of their own healthy genes, rather than a total stranger, whose vigour is unknown.
Equally, women could favour friends and workmates who have a paternal perfume. The dad partiality may have evolved to help people recognize and look after unfamiliar members of their own extended family.
Wayne Potts, of the University of Utah in Salt Lake City, favours the latter idea. "There are dozens of other reasons to choose partners," he says. When smells are judged out of context, it is difficult to know how this would affect everyday behaviour, he warns.
Sniffing the sheets
Women in Obers study snuffed mens two-night-old T-shirts. "Think of what your pillow and sheets smell like," suggests McClintock. These scents were presented to women, disguised in a box, alongside faint household odours such as clove, bleach and fresh laundry.
Men in the line-up each carried a different array of MHC genes, which are involved in fighting disease. Like vacillating brides, women were asked which scent they would choose if they had to smell it for the rest of their lives.
Women chose the scent of men whose array of MHC genes was similar to their own, the team found. The similar genes also matched, and were inherited from, the womans father.
Their choice was not down to familiarity with the odour from childhood. Women did not prefer the smell of a man whose MHC genes matched their fathers but not their own. If the preference were based simply on memory of the fathers smell, women would be less picky. "The genes are driving the preference," says McClintock.
Same but different
Each person carries a unique combination of MHC genes, which help to recognize foreign cells in the body. An earlier smelly T-shirt study showed that women choose men whose selection is different from their own2. This seems to conflict with Obers study, in which women preferred a whiff of genetic similarity.
Inbreeding with genetically similar partners can cause problems in children - but outbreeding with partners whose genes are totally different can also spell trouble. Choosing partners with an intermediate blend of disease-fighting genes may give future children the best chance of survival, the team suggests.
References
HELEN PEARSON | Source: © Nature News Service
Further information: www.nature.com/nsu/020114/020114-13.html
More articles from Life Sciences:
Elephant seal tracking reveals hidden lives of deep-diving animals
16.05.2012 | University of California - Santa Cruz
A marker in the lining of the lungs could be useful diagnostic technique for lung cancer screening
16.05.2012 | International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer
The first evidence in X-rays of a supernova shock wave breaking through a cocoon of gas around the star has been found.
This discovery may help explain why some supernova explosions are more powerful than others.
This supernova is called SN 2010jl and is found in a galaxy about 160 million light years from Earth.
SN 2010jl was first spotted by astronomers on November 3, 2010, and probably exploded about a month before that.
Observations with NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory have provided the first X-ray evidence of a supernova shock wave breaking through a cocoon of gas surrounding the star that exploded. This discovery may help astronomers understand why some supernovas are much more powerful than others.
On November 3, 2010, a supernova was ...
An international research team led by Gerd Weigelt from the Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie in Bonn reports on high-resolution studies of an active galactic nucleus.
The use of near-infrared interferometry allowed the team to resolve a ring-shaped dust distribution (generally called "dust torus") in the inner region of the nucleus of the active galaxy NGC 3783. This method is able to achieve an angular resolution equivalent to the resolution of a telescope with a diameter ...
Some populations of tiger snakes stranded for thousands of years on tiny islands surrounding Australia have evolved to be giants, growing to nearly twice the size of their mainland cousins. Now, new research in The American Naturalist suggests that the enormity of these elapids was driven by the need to have big-mouthed babies.
Mainland tiger snakes, which generally max out at 35 inches (89 cm) long, patrol swampy areas in search of frogs, their dietary staple. When sea levels rose around 10,000 years ago, some tiger snakes found themselves marooned on islands that would become dry and frog-free. With their favorite food gone, ...
HITS astrophysicists discover a new heating source in cosmological structure formation
So far, astrophysicists thought that super-massive black holes can only influence their immediate surroundings. A collaboration of scientists at the Heidelberg Institute for Theoretical Studies (HITS) and in Canada and the US now discovered that diffuse gas in the universe can absorb luminous gamma-ray emission from black holes, heating it ...
After ten years of development, the new German solar telescope GREGOR will start operating at the Spanish Observatorio del Teide of the Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias on Tenerife. It is the largest solar telescope in Europe and number three worldwide.
It will provide the German and the international community of solar physicists with new and better instrumentation which will enable them to investigate our home star in unprecedented detail.
Studying the Sun is a key to understand the physical processes on and in the majority of stars. Moreover, there is ...
New 'metamaterial' practical for optical advances
16.05.2012 | Materials Sciences
Timely discovery: Physics research sheds new light on quantum dynamics
16.05.2012 | Physics and Astronomy
The use of acoustic inversion to estimate the bubble size distribution in pipelines
16.05.2012 | Process Engineering
10.05.2012 | Event News
WWU hosts Germany’s Biggest Giftedness Congress
09.05.2012 | Event News
Neuroscientists Discuss Latest Research Results in Potsdam
08.05.2012 | Event News