Study looks at the pros and cons of voice recognition
Voice recognition dramatically decreases the turnaround time for radiology reports – referring physicians are often getting results the same day their patients have the radiologic examinations – but technical problems with these systems are reducing some radiologists to typing rather than dictating those reports, a new study shows.
“There are many benefits of voice recognition, but unfortunately we have been facing some technical problems that are impacting our productivity, ” says Joel Gross, MD, assistant professor of radiology at Harborview Medical Center in Seattle.
The biggest benefit of voice recognition is the reduction in report time turnaround, says Dr. Gross. “In 2001, when we used the traditional dictation system most of the time, it took an average 133 hours after the examination was completed before a report was finalized, says Dr. Gross. A preliminary report was available with 56 hours, notes Dr. Gross. (The traditional dictation method includes the radiologist dictating the report, a transcriptionist transcribing it, then the radiologist reading the transcribed report and making any necessary corrections before it is available to the referring physician as a finalized report.)
“With voice recognition as our main method (approximately 75%) of reporting in 2002, we have reduced that to 66 hours, with preliminary reports available within 14 hours,” he says. “This number is slightly skewed because it includes cases in which the patients undergo the exam late in the evening, and the films arent read until the following day. With most exams, voice recognition is allowing us to offer same day reporting service,” Dr. Gross says.
Another advantage of voice recognition is that a full report is available immediately to the radiologist. “At our teaching facility, the attending physician can more easily review cases with residents. There is not the delay caused by waiting for reports to be transcribed,” he says. “This allows full evaluation of all the details in the report while reviewing the images or while the study is still fresh in the radiologists mind. Signing off on traditional dictated reports several days after reviewing images, one is often reduced to looking for obvious errors in the reports,” he says.
However, “voice recognition is not a plug and play system,” says Dr. Gross. Faster computers are needed so the system doesnt freeze up. A good support team, available 24/7, that can fix problems or make necessary technical changes is essential, and must be budgeted for when making cost projections, he says. “Weve had problems with poor voice recognition, difficulty stopping the transcription, spell-checking, filtering reports, losing macros and speech files, and other glitches that have slowed us down,” says Dr. Gross.
“In addition weve also had problems with the system interfacing with our RIS system. Weve had situations where our voice recognition system has overwritten changes weve made to our reports in our RIS system, which could potentially lead to medico-legal problems,” he says. These technical problems have led some radiologists to simply type in the report themselves instead of dictating into the voice recognition system, says Dr. Gross. “These problems lead to a decrease in radiologists productivity and satisfaction,” he adds.
“Im optimistic that voice recognition will become a viable part of the radiology practice,” says Dr. Gross. “However, not only must there be improvements in the voice recognition technology itself, but other technical problems that impede efficiency must be addressed,” he says.
Dr. Gross will present his study May 5 during the American Roentgen Ray Society Annual Meeting in San Diego.
Keri J. Sperry, 703-858-4306
Danica Laub, 703-858-4332
Press Room: 619-525-6536
Alle Nachrichten aus der Kategorie: Studies and Analyses
innovations-report maintains a wealth of in-depth studies and analyses from a variety of subject areas including business and finance, medicine and pharmacology, ecology and the environment, energy, communications and media, transportation, work, family and leisure.
Do the twist: Making two-dimensional quantum materials using curved surfaces
Scientists at the University of Wisconsin-Madison have discovered a way to control the growth of twisting, microscopic spirals of materials just one atom thick. The continuously twisting stacks of two-dimensional…