Tackling antibiotic resistance via existing drugs (with a twist)
A scientific team from Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine and Cleveland Clinic has developed a new way to identify second-line antibiotics that may be effective in killing germs already resistant to a first-line antibiotic - potentially helping overcome antibiotic resistance.
Researchers developed a new way to identify second-line antibiotics that may be effective in killing germs already resistant to a first-line antibiotic -- potentially helping overcome antibiotic resistance. This new research provides an approach clinicians could consult when deciding which antibiotic treatment courses will be most effective for patients.
Credit: Jacob Scott, MD, DPhil
This new research provides an approach clinicians could consult when deciding which antibiotic treatment courses will be most effective for patients.
The method is based on a mathematical model created by Jacob Scott, MD, DPhil, principal investigator and associate staff member at Cleveland Clinic, and a clinical assistant professor at the medical school, and colleagues.
In a recent Nature Communications study, the researchers tested implications of the model in 60 different scenarios with a large panel of currently available antibiotics against E. coli strains that had evolved resistance to the widely-used antibiotic cefotaxime.
By using numerous evolution experiments, coupled with whole genome sequencing, they found drugs with a higher likelihood of being effective after resistance initially emerged to cefotaxime.
Once researchers expand these findings to a larger panel of initial therapies, physicians should be able to pinpoint with better accuracy which follow-up antibiotics are likely to work against resistant superbugs - overcoming a shortfall in current approaches.
Antibiotic resistance occurs when invading germs such as bacteria and fungi evolve the ability to outmaneuver antibiotics that used to wipe them out. Instead of being destroyed, the resulting superbugs thrive, sickening - and potentially killing - patients who, in the past, would have been healed by an effective medication.
While known for decades, the problem is worsening as a result of over-use of antibiotics in food and when treating patients. Each year in the U.S., at least two million people are infected with antibiotic-resistant bacteria, and at least 23,000 people die as a result.
The solution seems obvious: create new medicines to outwit the germs or use different antibiotics to see if they work instead. But bringing an average drug to market is expensive: $2.7 billion, according to a widely-used projection by the Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development.
And only a few new antibiotics have been developed over the past 30 years. There's another problem: "While new antibiotics may bring short- and medium-term relief, germs will eventually develop ways to outfox them," says Scott, who is also a physician-scientist in the department of Translational Hematology and Oncology Research at Cleveland Clinic Lerner Research Institute.
"Then we're back to where we started. That's just how evolution works. As the Red Queen tells Alice in Through the Looking Glass, 'It takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place.'"
The study's lead experimentalist, Robert A. Bonomo, MD, professor of medicine, pharmacology, molecular biology and microbiology at Case Western Reserve, and chief of medical service at the Louis Stokes Cleveland Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, makes it clear that he and his co-authors are not opposed to developing new medicines: "After all, that's what's been done in the past.
For example, tetracycline and erythromycin were developed decades ago when resistance surfaced against penicillin, and they've both proven very effective. And while germs will develop resistance to new medications, it may take years to do so. But correctly using existing medications can bring much quicker relief to patients and help keep health care costs contained."
In the new study, the authors administered a panel of different antibiotics to 60 E. coli strains that had been made resistant to cefotaxime. They then assessed whether the E. coli were killed off at higher or lower rates than E. coli that had not been made resistant to cefotaxime.
By using a much larger number of trials than is typical, the researchers overcame the problem of skewed results, which can lead clinicians to infer that a replacement antibiotic is more or less effective than it actually is when given to patients.
"Using a large number of what we term 'evolutionary replicates' explicitly accounts for the inherent randomness of evolution," said Bonomo. "If you only carry out a handful of tests, you are likely to miss the complexity of the evolutionary response of a bug to a second antibiotic."
In the case of ticarcillin, one of the antibiotics tested in the study, the researchers found that in only seven of the 60 replicates (11 percent of the time) did the resistant E. coli die at a higher rate compared pair-wise to E. coli not resistant to cefotaxime.
"This means that 89 percent of the time, this would be a bad second drug to give when dealing with cefotaxime-resistant E. coli," said the study's lead theorist, Daniel Nichol, DPhil, who undertook this research during his doctoral studies in the Department of Computer Science at the University of Oxford.
The authors found similar low rates of effectiveness for other drugs tested in the same drug family. "These findings serve as a cautionary warning that we may be inadvertently promoting resistance by prescribing follow-through drugs based on too few trials of their effectiveness."
"This paper is a first step in establishing a repository of findings that a clinician could consult in trying to determine how to deal with patients confronting CEF-resistant E. coli and eventually, other superbugs," said Scott. "We showed that not only is the common approach of using a few trials often less effective than hoped for, it may actually increase the risk to patients by wasting valuable time and resources in combating a serious infection."
Funding for the study was provided by the National Institutes of Health, National Cancer Institute, U. S. Department of Veterans Affairs, the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, Cleveland Department of Veterans Affairs, and the Cleveland Geriatric Research Education and Clinical Center.
Scott, J., Bonomo, R. et al. "Antibiotic collateral sensitivity is contingent on the repeatability of evolution." Nature Communications 10:334 (2019).
For more information about Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, please visit: case.edu/medicine.
Ansley Gogol | EurekAlert!
New 3D cultured cells mimic the progress of NASH
02.04.2020 | Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology
Geneticists are bringing personal medicine closer to recently admixed individuals
02.04.2020 | Estonian Research Council
Electrolytes play a key role in many areas: They are crucial for the storage of energy in our body as well as in batteries. In order to release energy, ions - charged atoms - must move in a liquid such as water. Until now the precise mechanism by which they move through the atoms and molecules of the electrolyte has, however, remained largely unknown. Scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research have now shown that the electrical resistance of an electrolyte, which is determined by the motion of ions, can be traced back to microscopic vibrations of these dissolved ions.
In chemistry, common table salt is also known as sodium chloride. If this salt is dissolved in water, sodium and chloride atoms dissolve as positively or...
Drops of water falling on or sliding over surfaces may leave behind traces of electrical charge, causing the drops to charge themselves. Scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research (MPI-P) in Mainz have now begun a detailed investigation into this phenomenon that accompanies us in every-day life. They developed a method to quantify the charge generation and additionally created a theoretical model to aid understanding. According to the scientists, the observed effect could be a source of generated power and an important building block for understanding frictional electricity.
Water drops sliding over non-conducting surfaces can be found everywhere in our lives: From the dripping of a coffee machine, to a rinse in the shower, to an...
90 million-year-old forest soil provides unexpected evidence for exceptionally warm climate near the South Pole in the Cretaceous
An international team of researchers led by geoscientists from the Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research (AWI) have now...
The bacteria that cause tuberculosis need iron to survive. Researchers at the University of Zurich have now solved the first detailed structure of the transport protein responsible for the iron supply. When the iron transport into the bacteria is inhibited, the pathogen can no longer grow. This opens novel ways to develop targeted tuberculosis drugs.
One of the most devastating pathogens that lives inside human cells is Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the bacillus that causes tuberculosis. According to the...
An international team with the participation of Prof. Dr. Michael Kues from the Cluster of Excellence PhoenixD at Leibniz University Hannover has developed a new method for generating quantum-entangled photons in a spectral range of light that was previously inaccessible. The discovery can make the encryption of satellite-based communications much more secure in the future.
A 15-member research team from the UK, Germany and Japan has developed a new method for generating and detecting quantum-entangled photons at a wavelength of...
06.04.2020 | Event News
02.04.2020 | Event News
26.03.2020 | Event News
06.04.2020 | Life Sciences
06.04.2020 | Power and Electrical Engineering
06.04.2020 | Social Sciences