COVID-19: Distancing and masks are not enough

Decades-old data is being used to describe the propagation of tiny droplets; now a fluid dynamics team has developed new models: Masks and distancing are good, but not enough.

Wear a mask, keep your distance, avoid crowds – these are the common recommendations to contain the COVID-19 epidemic. However, the scientific foundations on which these recommendations are based are decades old and no longer reflect the current state of knowledge.

To change this, several research groups from the field of fluid dynamics have now joined forces and developed a new, improved model of the propagation of infectious droplets. It has been shown that it makes sense to wear masks and maintain distances, but that this should not lull you into a false sense of security. Even with a mask, infectious droplets can be transmitted over several meters and remain in the air longer than previously thought.

TU Wien (Vienna), the University of Florida, the Sorbonne in Paris, Clarkson University (USA) and the MIT in Boston were involved in the research project. The new fluid dynamics model for infectious droplets was published in the “International Journal of Multiphase Flow“.

A new look on old data

“Our understanding of droplet propagation that has been accepted worldwide is based on measurements from the 1930s and 1940s”, says Prof. Alfredo Soldati from the Institute of Fluid Mechanics and Heat Transfer at TU Wien. “At that time, the measuring methods were not as good as today, we suspect that especially small droplets could not be measured reliably at that time”.

In previous models, a strict distinction was made between large and small droplets: The large droplets are pulled downwards by gravity, the small ones move forward almost in a straight line, but evaporate very quickly. “This picture is oversimplified,” says Alfredo Soldati. “Therefore, it is time to adapt the models to the latest research in order to better understand the propagation of COVID-19”.

From a fluid mechanics point of view, the situation is complicated – after all, we are dealing with a so-called multiphase flow: The particles themselves are liquid, but they move in a gas. It is precisely such multiphase phenomena that are Soldati’s specialty: “Small droplets were previously considered harmless, but this is clearly wrong,” explains Soldati. “Even when the water droplet has evaporated, an aerosol particle remains, which can contain the virus. This allows viruses to spread over distances of several meters and remain airborne for long time.”

In typical everyday situations, a particle with a diameter of 10 micrometers (the average size of emitted saliva droplets) takes almost 15 minutes to fall to the ground. So it is possible to come into contact with virus even when distancing rules are observed – for example in an elevator that was used by infected people shortly before. Particularly problematic are environments with high relative humidity, such as poorly ventilated meeting rooms. Special care is required in winter because the relative humidity is higher than in summer.

Protection rules: Useful, but not enough

“Masks are useful because they stop large droplets. And keeping a distance is useful as well. But our results show that neither of these measures can provide guaranteed protection,” says Soldati. With the mathematical model that has now been presented, and the current simulations under way it is possible to calculate the concentration of virus-carrying droplets at different distances at different times. “Until now, political decisions on COVID-protection measures have mainly been based on studies from the fields of virology and epidemiology. We hope that in the future, findings from fluid mechanics will also be included,” says Alfredo Soldati.

Contact

Prof. Alfredo Soldati
Institut für Strömungsmechanik und Wärmeübertragung
TU Wien
+43 1 58801 32213
alfredo.soldati@tuwien.ac.at