Five in every one hundred women suffer premenstrual symptoms at some time in their lives that are severe enough to interfere with their lives. One possible cause of the symptoms is the drop in progesterone that comes before menstruation. A suggested treatment, therefore, is to give women extra progesterone. But many health professionals doubt whether this treatment works.
To see if the research evidence can help resolve this, Cochrane Review Authors examined 17 different studies before performing a more detailed analysis of the data from the two trials which met their eligibility criteria. Of these, one trial of ‘better quality’ concluded that progesterone was more effective than placebo.
The main problem with assessing the benefit of progesterone is that 15 of the 17 trials had to be excluded for one or more important reasons. Some did not screen women for psychiatric disorders or persistence of symptoms after their menstrual periods, and others had to be excluded because the diagnosis of PMS was based on less than two cycles of symptom records. Probably because they needed to be run over many months, many trials also had a high drop out rate.
“The Review has revealed more about the difficulties inherent in the study of PMS and consequent deficiencies in method, than about the efficacy of progesterone in treating it,” says Lead Review Author Olive Ford former honorary Research Officer for the National Association for Premenstrual Syndrome.
Knowing whether progesterone is a useful treatment is complicated by the fact that treatments for PMS generally show large placebo effects. The Review Authors describe how some trials involving other therapies have found the placebo to have more effect than the treatment.
The Review points out that any women who do use progesterone need to be told of the mild side effects. These can include changes in menstrual cycle length and a tendency to become drowsy. In addition one woman who had believed herself to be infertile, conceived when taking progesterone, out of a total of about 650 women in all the trials examined.
Polly Young | Source: alphagalileo
Further information: www.thecochranelibrary.com
More articles from Health and Medicine:
Immune system activated in schizophrenia
20.11.2009 | Karolinska Institutet
New research helps explain why bird flu has not caused a pandemic
20.11.2009 | Imperial College London
Scientists Unravel Evolution of Highly Toxic Box Jellyfish
20.11.2009 | Life Sciences
When good companies do bad things: Examining illegal corporate behavior
20.11.2009 | Business and Finance
UCR plant scientist's research spawns new discoveries showing how crops survive drought
20.11.2009 | Agricultural and Forestry Science
Multidisciplinary meeting on Urological Cancers aims to benefit cancer patients
20.11.2009 | Event News
'Golden Age' for clinical psychology in Northern Ireland
20.11.2009 | Event News
New Perspectives in Marine Anti-Fouling Research
11.11.2009 | Event News