Skin in the Game–Mutual Funds and Performance

Less obvious is the importance of director incentives in mutual funds or the extent to which effective corporate governance is related to mutual fund performance. If ownership by directors plays an economically and statistically significant role in fund performance, it stands to reason that funds in which directors have low ownership, or “skin in the game,” significantly underperform.

New research by David Weinbaum, associate professor of finance in the Whitman School of Management at Syracuse University, hypothesizes that lack of ownership could indicate a director’s lack of alignment with fund shareholders interests. Co-written by Martijn Cremers, Joost Driessen, and Pascal Maenhout, and published in the Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, the research also investigates whether or not directors may have superior private information on future performance.

“We look at whether director ownership as a proxy for effective governance is associated with superior mutual fund performance and if so, what economic mechanism could explain that,” says Weinbaum.

Through use of a unique database on ownership stakes of equity mutual fund directors, the team analyzed whether effective mutual fund governance is related to performance, finding that direct ownership stakes are important for fund performance.

“Specifically, low ownership funds significantly underperform. Funds with higher ownership by non-independent directors have lower fees. However, this only explains part of the relation between ownership and performance.”

The team concluded that the link between low director ownership and poor fund performance were attributed to:
1. Lack of director incentives to act in the best interests of shareholders, and
2. Private information used by director when deciding in which funds to invest.
“However, the private information theory is untenable as we show that directors on average invest in funds that do not outperform the funds that they do not invest in,” says Weinbaum. “Therefore, the link between director ownership and fund performance is driven by the underperformance if funds that would benefit from improved alignment incentives in the form of director ownership, but where those incentives are missing.”

David Weinbaum is an associate professor of finance in the Whitman School of Management. He earned his PhD at NYU Stern. Weinbaum’s research interests are in investments, derivatives, mutual funds, and corporate governance. His current projects involve an analysis of the impact of director ownership on mutual fund performance, an examination of the effect of CEO perquisite disclosure on firm value, and an investigation of the information content of option prices for future stock returns.

Media Contact

Amy Schmitz Newswise Science News

More Information:

http://www.syr.edu

All latest news from the category: Business and Finance

This area provides up-to-date and interesting developments from the world of business, economics and finance.

A wealth of information is available on topics ranging from stock markets, consumer climate, labor market policies, bond markets, foreign trade and interest rate trends to stock exchange news and economic forecasts.

Back to home

Comments (0)

Write a comment

Newest articles

The Sound of the Perfect Coating

Fraunhofer IWS Transfers Laser-based Sound Analysis of Surfaces into Industrial Practice with “LAwave”. Sound waves can reveal surface properties. Parameters such as surface or coating quality of components can be…

Customized silicon chips

…from Saxony for material characterization of printed electronics. How efficient are new materials? Does changing the properties lead to better conductivity? The Fraunhofer Institute for Photonic Microsystems IPMS develops and…

Acetylation: a Time-Keeper of glucocorticoid Sensitivity

Understanding the regulatory mechanism paves the way to enhance the effectiveness of anti-inflammatory therapies and to develop strategies to counteract the negative effects of stress- and age-related cortisol excess. The…

Partners & Sponsors